
Written and reviewed by Hassaan Ullah Khan, PTIN-registered tax preparer and IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent. Last updated: 16 November 2026. General information; your home country’s tax rules also apply.
Side by side
| Single-member LLC (foreign owner) | C-Corp (foreign shareholder) | |
|---|---|---|
| US income tax on the company | None at company level; it is “disregarded” | 21% federal corporate tax on profit, plus any state tax |
| US tax on the owner | Only on income effectively connected with a US trade or business (Form 1040-NR) | Dividends paid to you: 30% withholding, reduced if your country has a tax treaty with the US |
| Yearly federal filings | Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 | Form 1120, plus Form 5472 if 25% or more is foreign-owned, and Forms 1042/1042-S for dividends |
| Typical states | New Mexico, Wyoming, Florida, Delaware | Delaware for investor-backed startups |
| Investors and stock options | Awkward; most VCs will not invest in an LLC | Standard: preferred shares, option pools, SAFEs |
| Paperwork | Operating agreement, light | Bylaws, board, share issuance, 83(b) elections for founders |
| Corpulate price | Starter $199 + state fee | Startup C-Corp $499 + state fee |
How the LLC is taxed when you live abroad
A single-member LLC owned by a non-US person is ignored for US income tax: the profit is treated as yours. Whether the US taxes it depends on one question: is it effectively connected with a US trade or business? Signs that it is include a US office or warehouse you control, US employees or agents who make deals for you, or work you physically do while in the US. Service income for work you do entirely from abroad is generally foreign-source and not taxed by the US.
Either way, the LLC files Form 5472 with a pro forma 1120 every year. If it does have connected income, you also file Form 1040-NR. Your home country normally taxes the profit as your income.
How the C-Corp is taxed
A C-Corp is a separate US taxpayer. It pays 21% federal tax on its worldwide profit, whoever owns it, and files Form 1120. When it pays you a dividend, it must withhold 30%, or the lower treaty rate if your country has a treaty with the US and you give the company a Form W-8BEN. Your home country may then tax the dividend too, often with a credit for US tax. Salary paid to you for work done abroad is generally not US-source income, but it must be reasonable and documented.
Which one for you?
- Freelancer, consultant, agency, online seller, no US investors: LLC.
- Startup raising from US angels or VCs, or Y Combinator-style accelerators: Delaware C-Corp.
- Selling through Amazon FBA with inventory in US warehouses: often still an LLC, but have a preparer check whether that creates connected income.
- You want to keep profits in the company to reinvest: a C-Corp’s 21% rate can work, but compare with your home-country rules first.
Switching later
You can start with an LLC and change later. An LLC can elect to be taxed as a corporation by filing Form 8832 with the IRS, or convert to a corporation under state law; startups raising money usually convert to a Delaware C-Corp before the first priced round. Converting has tax consequences, so plan it with a preparer.
Common mistakes
- Forming a C-Corp “to look bigger” and then paying 21% tax plus dividend withholding on profit an LLC would not have been taxed on.
- Forming an LLC when investors are already lined up, then paying for a conversion months later.
- Forgetting the yearly federal filing: Form 5472 for the LLC, Form 1120 for the C-Corp. Penalties start at $25,000.
Related
Official sources
